Black Hills Energy agrees to delay monthly surcharge request
Black Hills Energy has reversed course and will not try to immediately impose a new monthly surcharge on its electric customers while South Dakota regulators consider the request.
The surcharge could still be implemented later, though, and it would further raise monthly bills for Black Hills Energy customers already dealing with a regular rate increase.
That rate increase, approved by the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission on Nov. 5, adds about $16 per month to the typical Black Hills Energy residential customer’s monthly electric bill. Bills also increased for businesses. Black Hills Energy has about 75,000 electric customers in western South Dakota.
Black Hills Energy has also requested to implement a temporary monthly surcharge to pay for the ongoing construction of its Lange II natural-gas-fired power plant in Rapid City. The company initially said the surcharge would be $19.70 a month for a typical residential customer using 650 kilowatt-hours per month, but has since said it would be $17.26 for a typical residential customer using 600 kilowatt-hours per month.
Commissioner Chris Nelson highlighted the discrepancy during Tuesday’s hearing.
“I would encourage Black Hills to figure out what the right number is, and then communicate that so we can all be using the same number there,” Nelson said.
Merger of NorthWestern Energy, Black Hills Corp. lands in Montana court
The company had hoped to start collecting the surcharge on an interim basis starting Dec. 1 while the commission reviews the request.
Commission staff challenged the interim request, arguing state law does not give the utility authority to impose a surcharge on an interim basis before it’s approved. That authority is often granted in regular rate-hike reviews, and customers are refunded if the commission later reduces or rejects the rate increase.
Under a new agreement, the legal argument is not settled, but Black Hills Energy will not seek to implement the surcharge before Feb. 1 or the date its new Rapid City power plant starts operating — whichever is later.
The agreement delays the utility’s attempt to begin collecting about $37.5 million annually from South Dakota customers to recover costs associated with the plant, which will cost approximately $320 million to build. The surcharge would be subject to annual review by the commission.
During Thursday’s commission hearing, an attorney representing Black Hills Energy said the expected startup of the Lange II plant had been delayed, contributing to the company’s decision to withdraw its interim surcharge request.
The state’s three elected commissioners voted unanimously to defer consideration of the legal dispute over interim surcharges indefinitely, given the agreement reached with the company.
“I think there’s a real legal question as to whether you can even do that,” said Nelson, speaking of the interim surcharge request. “Hopefully, we don’t have to adjudicate that, but if we do at some point, well, that’s why we’re here.”
Black Hills Energy recently announced the completion of a merger with NorthWestern Energy to form parent company Bright Horizon Energy, but Montana’s regulatory approval of the merger is being challenged in court. The merged companies would have 2.2 million electric or natural gas customers across eight states.
However, Black Hills Energy and NorthWestern Energy will “continue to operate and file for rates separately,” according to a June statement from Public Utilities Commissioner Kristie Fiegen.