Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Judge to hold hearing on petition to suspend order on NorthWestern merger

Share

Judge to hold hearing on petition to suspend order on NorthWestern merger

Nov 19, 2026 | 7:00 pm ET
By Keila Szpaller
Judge to hold hearing on petition to suspend order on NorthWestern merger
Description
Electricity pylons (Photo by Getty Images).

A district court judge will hold a hearing on a request to stop a Montana Public Service Commission order approving the merger of Montana’s largest utility company.

NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Corp announced Monday the utilities had completed the merger and formed Bright Horizon Energy. The new company spans eight states.

But the deal remains subject to reconsideration and judicial review. Montana was the last state that needed to approve the merger.

This week, 350 Montana and Montana Farmers Union asked the court to stop the order that greenlit the merger with conditions.

They argue it doesn’t adequately account for the risks to Montana ratepayers. The two groups participated in the merger case.

The PSC approved the order last Tuesday but closed part of the meeting to the public, and the parties also allege the closure was a violation of the Montana Constitution.

The state constitution protects people’s right to observe government deliberations except when individual privacy “clearly exceeds” disclosure.

The PSC closed the meeting after Commissioner Randy Pinocci asked a question about potential litigation.

The parties said Montana Supreme Court precedent doesn’t offer exceptions to the right to observe government for attorney-client deliberations or agency “convenience.”

Through lawyer Monica Tranel, the parties also asked the court to grant an immediate stay, or suspension, of the order, and request judicial review of the case.

The parties argue the matter needs attention now — not after it’s impossible to undo the merger if a judge finds the deal harms Montanans as alleged.

“A stay preserves judicial review,” the parties said. “Without it, the court is not deciding this case later. No one is.”

In an order late Wednesday, Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Kathy Seeley said the court can’t suspend the order without first holding a hearing.

The judge scheduled it for 9 a.m. Thursday, Dec. 10.

Seeley requested the parties be prepared to discuss a schedule for the case at the hearing.

A spokesperson for the PSC could not be reached for comment Thursday.